What is a false log and when will one result in an out-of-service order?
Recently, the Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance (CVSA) changed the out-of-service criteria related to false logs. However, the change did not affect what constitutes a false log and when a violation for a false log will be written.
What is ‘false’
A false log is a driver’s record of duty status (log), either paper or electronic, that does not truthfully reflect the driver’s activities. Common examples of false logs include:
- An electronic logging device (ELD) log that shows the driver as being logged out while the vehicle is moving,
- A paper log or ELD log that shows the driver using personal conveyance when the reason for the movement is company-related,
- A paper log or ELD log that has duty time logged on the wrong duty line (as in on-duty time logged as off-duty time, sleeper time logged as off-duty time or vice-versa), and
- A paper or ELD log that shows a ghost driver as a co-driver.
In all such cases, the driver will be given a violation for operating with a false log. The next step for the officer will be deciding if the driver is to be placed out of service due to the violation.
The out-of-service decision
To determine if the driver will be placed out of service, the officer will review the requirements in the North American Standard Out-of-Service Criteria, published by CVSA. To place the driver out of service, the officer will need to determine the falsification was an attempt to “hide” on-duty hours, and:
- The falsification has taken place since the drivers last 8-hour or 10-hour break (8 hour for passenger-carrying driver, 10 hours for passenger carrying driver), and/or
- The driver is currently over hours once the hidden hours are added into the driver’s on-duty totals.
Therefore, in the case of the driver that logged off-duty rather than sleeper, the driver will not be placed out of service. This is because there was no attempt to hide on-duty hours and when the driver’s hours are recalculated, it will not result in the driver being over an hours limit.
On the other hand, if the driver used personal conveyance after the last 10-hour break, the driver would be placed out of service. This is due to the falsification taking place since the driver’s last 10-hour break.
Finally, if a driver falsified off-duty time three days ago (the time was recorded as off-duty rather than on-duty time) and when the time is changed from off-duty to on-duty the driver is over the 60- or 70-hour limit, the driver will be placed out of service. This would include a driver that incorrectly logged an on-duty activity as off-duty time (such as fueling or loading/unloading) or a driver that incorrectly logged driving time as personal conveyance.
Key to remember: While all incidents of false logs will be cited during a roadside inspection, the decision on placing the driver out of service will be based on the specific situation.