What if an employee requests FMLA leave AFTER deciding to terminate?
Thomas started working for the company in May 2022. Less than a year later, the employer noticed some job performance issues. Rosie, Thomas’ supervisor, told him to create an improvement action plan, but Thomas continued to struggle. The employer then created a formal Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) they would review together on September 29, 2023.
During the week of September 4, however, another manager indicated that Thomas had become a liability for the company. The managers decided to fire Thomas on September 14 or 15.
On September 8, Thomas sought medical attention due to depression. His doctor put him on medication and talked about other treatments. The medication made Thomas tired and nauseous. On Sunday, September 10, Thomas emailed Rosie saying, “I am not feeling well, and I anticipate that I will be able to return Wednesday.” Thomas missed work on September 11 and 12.
Rosie interpreted Thomas’ email as him opting to take a sick day for a minor illness.
On September 12, Thomas uploaded a doctor’s note to the company’s HR system. The note said he was ill and unable to work on the 11th and 12th, but it provided no other information.
Thomas returned to work on September 13. Rosie scheduled a meeting with him for the following day. Meanwhile, Thomas had another doctor’s appointment on the 13th, when he was told he needed at least three weeks of leave.
After the doctor's appointment, Thomas submitted a request for leave under the federal Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA). Despite having worked on September 13, he said he’d been on leave since September 11. Thomas also emailed Rosie later that afternoon informing the employer for the first time of his need for a medical leave.
At the September 14 meeting, the employer fired Thomas.
Thomas sued, arguing the employer violated the FMLA because his leave began September 11.
The court pointed out that Thomas submitted an FMLA leave request on September 13, saying he had been off work for FMLA since September 11. This was impossible, as Thomas submitted the FMLA request on September 13. Thomas also worked on the 13th and 14th, making any statement that he had been “off work for FMLA since September 11, 2023” inaccurate.
Thomas didn’t tell Rosie that he needed to explore leave until September 13, 2023, at 4:05 p.m. The employer had decided to terminate Thomas on September 12, 2023, at 3:40 p.m., one day before Thomas requested FMLA leave.
In ruling for the employer, the court said the timeline showed that Thomas’ request for leave was made after the employer approved his termination, making it inconceivable that his FMLA request led to his termination.
Daniels v. Morningstar, Inc., Northern District of Illinois, No. 24-cv-00289, April 3, 2025.
Key to remember: Employer termination decisions made before an employee requests FMLA leave may stand, particularly if those making the decision have no information about a leave request.