What to say to an employer who wants to hire someone that you fired
Background checks are often an important part of the hiring process. However, you may not know what to say when another employer is checking on an employee you fired.
Having a company policy regarding the sharing of information on former employees can help, whether they left your company voluntarily or involuntarily.
Follow company policy
A policy should outline exactly how much (and what) information the company will provide. The policy might differentiate between former employees who consented to the sharing of information and those who did not, or between those who left on good terms versus those who were fired.
Your company may have a standard response for the latter situation, such as “Yes, they worked here, but we would not rehire them.”
Without written consent from the former employee, you may decide to only give basic information, such as dates of employment and job title. With the former employee’s consent, you could furnish more information, such as the reason for termination and whether the employee would be eligible for rehire. For someone who held a driving position, a vehicle accident record could be provided.
Even with the former employee’s consent, however, employers still have the option in most cases to refuse to provide any further information.
Use caution when explaining terminations
If your company shares reasons for discharge, be cautious about the wording. Avoid overly negative or accusatory remarks.
For example, saying that a former employee was discharged for stealing could subject the company to a claim of libel or slander unless you have adequate proof of theft, such as a confession or conviction. If you say that an employee was let go because they were disabled and couldn’t work, this could give rise to an Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) claim.
Make sure everyone is on the same page
One or a select few employees should be trained to handle requests for information on previous employees. Those employees should understand the significance of the information they are providing.
When a company has multiple facilities or locations the policy should be communicated to managers and supervisors in each location. Often, they are the ones who are contacted by a prospective employer so they should understand how your company handles these matters. Some companies require that all reference requests be sent to a central location for handling.
NOT sharing may be trouble too
Your company might be liable if it only provides minimal information about an employee discharged for some type of assault or violence in the workplace.
You may be legally obligated to disclose this information to the prospective employer. If you fail to reveal such information to the next potential employer, your company could be held liable for damages if your ex-employee was hired and then committed an assault which resulted in severe injury or death.
Finally, if you employ drivers regulated by the Department of Transportation (DOT), be sure your company abides by the DOT rules which requires furnishing positive drug test results to the new employer.
Key to remember: Don’t be caught off guard by other employers asking about former employees. Have a company policy about how much information should be shared and make sure supervisors and managers at all locations are aware of the policy.