The intersection of the Canada ELD Mandate and the US ELD Requirements
In the dynamic world of transportation regulations, carriers may find themselves at a crossroads — at the intersection of Canada’s electronic logging device (ELD) mandate and the U.S. ELD requirements. While both intersect to enhance safety and streamline recordkeeping, their divergent paths reveal nuances in regulations, technical specifications, and enforcement. Carriers must choose wisely, ensuring compliance with the rules of their operating territories. As the digital era reshapes the road ahead, understanding these differences becomes paramount for a seamless journey toward safer roads and efficient operations.
In this article, we delve into the key distinctions between the Canada ELD mandate and the US ELD requirements, shedding light on how carriers can traverse these regulatory crossroads.
Common goals
Both the Canada ELD mandate and the U.S. ELD requirements share the common goal of promoting safety, reducing fatigue-related accidents, and ensuring accurate hours-of-service (HOS) records. Carriers operating in either country must stay informed about the specific regulations and choose ELDs that meet the respective standards. Compliance not only avoids penalties but also contributes to safer roads and a more efficient transportation industry. But this is where the commonalities largely end. This comparison between the two ELD mandates clearly shows where:
Canada | United States | |
Applicability | This applies to federally regulated drivers and carriers operating within Canada. Enforced by provinces and territories. Technical standard created by the Canadian Council of Motor Transport Administrators (CCMTA). | Applicable to interstate commercial motor drivers and carriers Enforced by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) |
Implementation | Implementation June 2021, no grandfathering provisions | Mandate adopted Dec. 2015; mandate effective Dec. 2017; grandfathering for carriers using AOBRDs ended Dec. 2019 |
Certification | ELD 3rd party certification | ELD provider self-certification |
Exemptions | Limited exemptions for: drivers operating under a permit or statutory exemption; drivers operating a rental CMV for 30 days or less; drivers operating CMVs manufactured before the year 2000 Exemptions by industry may be requested through Transport Canada | Drivers operating a rental CMV for 8 days or less; pre-2000 exemption is the same as Canada; also, multiple industry/situational exemptions |
Notifications | Compliance with the limits must be tracked and driver must be warned 30 minutes before reaching a limit | U.S. devices must only record, no warning required |
Malfunctions | 14 days to replace or, if the trip is longer than 14 days, upon return to the terminal; carrier must keep records of malfunctions | Up to 8 days allowed, no recordkeeping requirement |
Roadside Inspection Enforcement | Display or print the record of duty status; email records upon request by enforcement. Bluetooth/USB transfer is an option, not mandatory Carry 14 days’ worth of blank logs | Display or printout or Bluetooth/USB/web/email is required (must transfer using one of 4 methods.) Email direct to officer is not an option. Carry 8 days’ worth of blank logs |
North of 60N | Device must have the ability to change when crossing 60N ruleset (to Yukon and Northwest Territories) | Not applicable |
Balancing nuances
Carriers must navigate these nuances, understanding exemptions, data transfer methods, and enforcement practices specific to where their drivers are operating. Failing to do so can result in fines, penalties, and negative events on the carrier’s safety record. As the road ahead unfolds, compliance remains the compass, guiding carriers toward safer highways and efficient operations.
Key to remember: While the overarching goal remains the same—to enhance safety and improve compliance with hours-of-service regulations—the specific ELD requirements differ significantly between the two countries.