DOT pre-employment tests: Three common points of confusion
Driver turnover is rampant, making DOT pre-employment drug testing a common occurrence for many motor carriers. But misunderstanding pre-employment requirements can put you in violation of the safety regulations.
Consider the following three common topics that often confuse those delegated with sending drivers for pre-employment tests.
1. Identifying refusals to test
The definition of refusal to test has some lesser-known caveats for pre-employment tests.
If a driver-applicant backs out of the hiring process and fails to show up for a scheduled test, this is not a refusal to test. In fact, even if the driver shows up and is waiting to be called back for testing, the driver can leave the facility any time prior to testing without consequence. But once led back for testing and the process starts, the driver can’t leave.
In the event of an inadequate specimen, the driver must remain at the site for a set period to attempt to provide a new sample. The driver must stay three hours for a urine collection and one hour for oral-fluid drug testing. Leaving before time is up constitutes a refusal to test.
If the driver is unable to provide an adequate specimen even after staying for the required period, there are stipulations before a medical review officer (MRO) can deem the test a refusal. The MRO will instruct the driver to seek a medical evaluation. If the driver fails to do so, the MRO can report a refusal to test if the test was conducted following a contingent offer of employment. If there was no employment offer, the MRO must cancel the test.
2. Handling failed tests
Many carriers mistakenly treat pre-employment test results differently than other tests. Some believe a second test will nullify a failed pre-employment test if they wait long enough. But a failed pre-employment test holds the same consequences any other test and is reported to the Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse. Another pre-employment test with a negative result does not remove the violation.
Regardless of whether the carrier hires the driver, the driver must be provided a list of substance abuse professionals. The drug testing form and MRO result (or record of refusal to test) are kept in the carrier’s records at least five years.
Since the event is reported to the Clearinghouse, the driver will be placed in a Prohibited Status until the necessary steps in the return-to-duty process are complete. The driver is also subject to follow-up testing.
3. Proper use of the exception
The exception to pre-employment testing entails more than just having been in a carrier’s testing program within the past 30 days.
The regulation (382.301(b)) requires that all the following be true:
- The driver was in a Part 382 program within the past 30 days, and while in the program:
- Was drug tested within the past 6 months, OR was in the random pool for 12 consecutive months; and
- The former employer doesn’t have knowledge of a DOT drug test violation under any DOT agency in the past 6 months.
If the driver appears to qualify, the motor carrier must contact all former FMCSA employers in the past 6 months (to accommodate the failed drug test piece) and request the data elements outlined in 382.301(c). The motor carrier will need the driver’s specific written consent for the former employer to respond.
Motor carriers need this documentation in hand (similar to having a negative pre-employment test result) prior to allowing the driver to perform a safety-sensitive function. Note there is no set response time in the regulations, so a new employer might be left waiting on a former employer. Use of the exception then becomes a business decision depending how quickly you need the driver.
Key to remember: If a motor carrier is not aware of the nuances associated with pre-employment testing, they may find themselves in violation of the safety regulations.