Dealing with unassigned driving time is a big deal
Unassigned driving time, which is created any time a driver drives without logging into the electronic logging device, is either a mistake made by someone or an attempt to falsify a log. The only way you can tell the difference is by investigating.
The rules require…
Under 395.32, when there is unassigned driving in the unassigned driver account, the carrier must either:
- Assign the driving time to the proper driver, or
- Attach an annotation (comment) to the unassigned driving time explaining why it could not be assigned.
There is no third option.
The reason the regulations require a carrier to do this is because one of the most common ways drivers falsify when using an ELD is to:
- Log out and continue to drive when out of hours,
- Log in late to “create” a 10-hour break when one didn’t exist (8-hour for a passenger carrying driver), or
- Log in late to “save” hours for later in the day.
Investigative decision tree
To determine whether you are dealing with a driver that made an error, a driver that is attempting to falsify, or a vehicle that was moved by a non-driver, you need to conduct an investigation. Like any investigation, you want to follow a standard process, so nothing is missed. A possible model is to collect, analyze, and then take action.
Collect
The first step in any investigation is collecting data. The data you need to collect includes:
- ELD records for all drivers that operated the vehicle in question during the day in question. This can be combined with other data later to determine the driver involved.
- Dispatch and payroll records for the date in question. This is needed to determine the drivers before and after the unassigned driving time, and if any other drivers were in a position to operate the vehicle.
- Maintenance and repair records for the vehicle. These are needed to determine if a mechanic could have moved the vehicle.
- Other supporting documents. This includes shipment paperwork, expense reimbursements, and electronic system records (electronic communications).
- Position data from the unassigned driving time. This shows the distance the vehicle moved (a long distance on the road or a short distance in a yard) and can help indicate what driver was involved.
- Interviews with any drivers that could have driven the vehicle. This can provide a direct solution or provide guidance on other data that may be necessary.
Analyze
The second step is to analyze the data. This involves looking at all of the data and coming up with the most likely scenario. As an example, if one driver drove the vehicle before and after the unassigned driving time, and none of the other documents indicate another person could have driven the vehicle, you have likely solved the mystery.
If, during your investigation, you determine that adding the unassigned hours into the likely driver’s log would put the driver over hours, start looking at the situation as a falsification.
Take action
Once you have determined who was driving the vehicle without logging in, take the action necessary, based on your findings. If the driver made an error (such as forgetting to log in), it is a simple matter of assigning the driving time to the driver and counseling the driver, so the errors stop. If it is a matter that the driver was logged out in an attempt to hide driving time, discipline the driver as you would any other driver that submits a false log or document. If it turns out that the vehicle was moved by a non-driver (such as a mechanic, based on the maintenance records), add a comment to the unassigned driving time explaining why it could not be assigned to a driver.
Key to remember: If you are not investigating unassigned driving time every time it happens, you are likely missing a log of false logs.