Crash Preventability Determination Program update being proposed
The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) is proposing an update to the Crash Preventability Determination Program (CPDP).
What is the CPDP and why is this important news?
The CPDP allows a carrier to request the review of a crash. If it is found not-preventable, the crash will not be scored in the carrier’s Crash BASIC in the Compliance, Safety, Accountability program. This is big news because FMCSA is proposing to expand the list of crash types they review.
Current program
Currently, a carrier can request a review for these types of crashes:
- The CMV was struck in the rear or on the rear corner (7:00 and 5:00 positions);
- The CMV was struck by a motorist driving the wrong direction, a motorist that was struck by another motorist going in the wrong direction, or a motorist making an illegal turn or U-turn;
- The CMV was struck when it was legally stopped or parked;
- The CMV was struck by another vehicle that failed to slow or stop in traffic, or a vehicle that failed to stop for a traffic control device (such as a red stop light or stop sign);
- The other party involved in the crash or incident was under the influence or the CMV is struck by a vehicle that was struck by another motorist that was under the influence;
- The other driver suffered a medical emergency, admitted to falling asleep, or admitted to driving when distracted;
- The crash involved cargo, equipment, or debris striking the CMV, or an infrastructure failure;
- The CMV struck an animal;
- The other party committed suicide or attempted suicide by crashing into or stepping in front of the CMV; and
- The CMV was involved in a non-preventable rare or unusual crash (such as the CMV being hit by an out-of-control skydiver).
To request a preventability review, the carrier must initiate a DataQs request for data review (RDR) asking for a preventability determination. The carrier must provide a copy of the police accident report (PAR) and any other documents the carrier can submit to support its argument.
If the carrier does not submit its copy of the PAR or does not respond to FMCSA’s requests for follow-up information, the crash will be found ineligible (and no determination will be made) or the determination of “undecided” will be assigned to the crash. If there was a fatality, the post-crash drug and alcohol test results are also required.
Additional crash types eligible for review
If the proposed update is adopted, FMCSA would also accept preventability RDRs for the following type of crashes:
- The CMV was struck on the side by a motorist going the same direction (would require a PAR indicating the other party struck the CMV).
- The CMV was struck because another motorist was entering the roadway from a private driveway or parking lot.
- The CMV was struck because another motorist lost control of their vehicle (would require a PAR indicating the other party lost control prior to striking the CMV).
- Any type of crash where video provided by the carrier demonstrates the crash was not-preventable.
Key to remember: Adding to the list of crash types eligible for review is currently a proposal. Should these changes be adopted into the program, carriers will have the ability to ask for preventability determinations on more crashes.