Is returning roadside inspection reports optional? It’s complicated!
Because of the instructions on some roadside inspection reports, a question we have been receiving lately is, "Do we have to return a signed copy of the report?" The answer is, "It depends."
To put it simply, under the current policy, the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) allows states to modify the process detailed in the regulations at 396.9, when it comes to the returning of the roadside inspection reports.
As a result, some states want all returned, some states only want them returned if there is a defect or violation listed (this is the process outlined in the regulations at 396.9), and other states do not want them returned at all (returning them is optional in these states). To determine what needs to be done, you must read the instructions at the bottom of the report.
Possible change coming
Currently, the FMCSA has a petition for rulemaking before them to change the regulation to reflect the practices currently used by the states. That petition is expected to be granted and the regulation changed sometime in the next couple of years.
What is going to be looked at during an audit
What the FMSCA and state investigators look for during an audit is that a carrier has their copy of the report for all inspections in the previous 12 months (with the carrier official signature on it), that the ones issued by states that require the report to be returned were returned, and that there are maintenance records showing that:
- Any OOS violations were repaired before the vehicle operated again, and
- Any non-OOS defects listed were repaired either on the day of the inspection or as a result of a DVIR the driver submitted at the end of the day (if the defect was not repaired the day of the inspection – see 396.11).
Key to remember: Whether the roadside inspection report is to be returned is actually up to the state involved, so be sure to read the instructions in the report.