COVID-19 stifled EPA inspections in FY 2020
Federal EPA’s enforcement report for Fiscal Year (FY) 2020 shows the agency conducted 3,202 on-site inspections (not including off-site monitoring and reporting activities). This figure is almost a 61 percent drop compared to FY 2019, which had 8,167 on-site inspections, and a 77 percent drop from the number of inspections it conducted in FY 2010 (13,903), after which inspection counts began to plummet.
COVID-19 prompted more off-site monitoring
The agency explains that the COVID-19 public health emergency (which took hold during 8 months of FY 2020) severely constrained EPA’s ability to perform on-site inspections in the field. Hence, EPA on-site inspectors could only reach 39 percent of the sites they could in FY 2019.
In response, the agency emphasized off-site compliance monitoring activities, which don’t require inspectors to visit a site to determine a facility’s compliance. EPA performed 4,926 of these off-site monitoring activities in FY 2020, but only 815 in the previous fiscal year. The grand total of inspections and monitoring came to 8,128 in FY 2020, or a 9.5 percent shortfall from 8,982 in FY 2019.
Civil cases
Civil penalties reached $159.25M in FY 2020, which is far less than the $365.90M pulled in during FY 2019. The agency argues that annual total civil penalties are often strongly influenced by one or two large cases; therefore, dollar figures vary each year.
EPA initiated and concluded almost 1,600 civil judicial and administrative cases in FY 2020, slightly less than the almost 1,700 cases in FY 2019. However, it was below half the 3,400 cases in FY 2010.
Criminal cases
The number of opened criminal cases climbed 45 percent to 247 in FY 2020, from 170 in FY 2019. Again, this was still lower than the 345 cases opened in FY 2010.
Criminal penalties fell 61 percent from $110.05M in FY 2019 down to $42.44M in FY 2020. Like civil penalties, criminal penalty totals vary widely due to large cases. The number of years of incarceration also dropped in FY 2020 to 44 years, from 91 years in FY 2019. Incarceration years will fluctuate year to year, but these totals have reached as high as 160 years in EPA’s history.