Age is just a number; a number you shouldn't know
Occasionally, a detail in a news story will make me want to smack my head and utter a Homer Simpson-style, “Doh!”
That was my reaction when I read about a recent age discrimination lawsuit.
Earlier this summer, a jury in Wisconsin determined that an internet-based auto parts seller violated federal law when it failed to hire a qualified job applicant because of his age.
According to this Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) lawsuit, the applicant, named Glenn, applied for a position as a supply chain manager at the company’s headquarters. Glenn had years of relevant experience, as well as relevant bachelor’s and master’s degrees.
The employer, after receiving Glenn’s application, emailed him to ask in what year he received his undergraduate degree. This is where I want to smack my head and say, “Doh!”
Glenn revealed a graduation year more than 20 years prior to his application, and the company rejected him the next day. Other significantly younger applicants who lacked Glenn’s experience and credentials passed through its interview and hiring process, the EEOC charged. The jury trial only took two days.
I’m envisioning the jury members simultaneously shouting “Doh!” when that bit about the email came up.
The Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA) forbids age discrimination against people who are age 40 or older. If Glenn earned his bachelor’s degree 20 years ago, he’s either over age 40 or he was a child savant. Thus, asking what year he earned his degree was the equivalent of asking his age.
Lessons from this case: Not only should you avoid directly asking an applicant’s age, you shouldn’t go through the back door and ask an indirect question that will lead you to know an applicant’s age either.
Besides “When did you graduate?” other questions to avoid include, “How old were you when the first Star Wars movie came out?” “Did you learn how to type on a manual typewriter, or an IBM Selectric?” or “Do you remember where you were when the Challenger exploded?”
It’s best to focus on a job candidate’s skills and stick to job-related questions.
Further, if you stumble upon an applicant’s age (maybe dates are included on a resume and you can’t stop yourself from doing the math), try to put it out of your head. Smacking yourself and shouting, “DOH!” may help.