Expert Insights: Policies are not laws, but they can violate laws
I recently read a statement indicating that it is not uncommon for some HR professionals to mistake company policies for laws. This reminded me that some company policies can actually violate laws.
ADA
Take, for example, a workplace policy that requires all employees to disclose all the medications they are taking. This violates the federal Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Under the ADA, employers may ask medical questions (such as asking about medications) or require medical exams, only when they have a reasonable belief, based on objective evidence, that a particular employee is unable to perform the job’s essential functions because of a medical condition, or will pose a direct threat because of a medical condition.
Note: If another federal law requires the question/exam, it does not violate the ADA.
The focus has to be on a particular employee, not a group of employees or all employees. Since the policy applies to all employees, it flies in the face of the ADA.
Another popular policy is to require employees returning from a medical-related absence to be 100% healed and have no restrictions. This violates the ADA’s requirement to provide reasonable accommodations.
The ADA can be sneaky. If employers think it doesn’t apply unless they have an employee in a wheelchair, they can risk expensive claims.
Then there’s the FMLA
The federal Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) is another law where a related policy can pose risks. If, for example, employers have a policy requiring employees to miss more than three days of work before considering whether the absence qualifies for protection under the federal Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA), they risk a violation.
In many situations, any period of incapacity is protected by the FMLA; no need for a three-day absence. These include:
- Pregnancy,
- Chronic conditions,
- Long-term/permanent conditions, and
- Conditions for which treatment is not effective.
The more-than-three-days provision relates to the duration of the impairment, not the duration of the workdays missed.
Go to the head of the class
Because policies apply to multiple employees (a class of people), lawsuits involving policies can become class actions. This increases the financial risks.
Key to remember: Employers must ensure that company policies don’t go too far and risk violating employment laws.