Take the confusion out of personal conveyance authorization with this checklist
The use of personal conveyance is an ongoing industry issue. Adding to the confusion is the latest version of the interpretation creating the exemption (Question 26 to Section 395.8), and the frequently asked questions (FAQs) the Federal Motor Carrier Administration (FMCSA) has published on the topic.
To determine if a movement can qualify as personal conveyance, look at the whole situation. Then, compare it to the guidance provided in the interpretation and FAQs. For example, if the driver is routinely dispatched from home, movements to and from the driver’s home cannot be considered personal conveyance. However, if the driver leaves the assigned route line to go home or is commuting to and from the terminal to home, then the driving can be logged as personal conveyance.
The current personal conveyance interpretation also allows personal conveyance to be used if a driver who is out of hours is asked to move the vehicle by a shipper, receiver, or officer. However, in this case the interpretation is clear in that the movement can only be to the nearest safe parking place, regardless of direction. A driver cannot go down their intended route line to find a safe parking place if there is safe place to park closer in another direction.
To make this easier, here is a checklist that can be used when determining if a movement can be considered personal conveyance. This checklist can be used to provide authorization before the movement or auditing after it has occurred.
Routine personal conveyance (PC):
- Does/did the use of PC match the company PC policy? Y/N
- Is/was the driver legitimately off duty (not on duty) during the PC? Y/N
- Is/was the driver’s destination for the PC movement purely personal? Y/N
- Is/was there no benefit to the company as a result of the PC movement (including the vehicle ending up in a better location for the current or next assignment)? Y/N
PC as the result of the driver being ordered to move by a shipper, receiver, or officer:
- Will/did the driver note in the record the identity of the person that required the vehicle to be moved ? Y/N
- Will/did the driver move the vehicle to the nearest safe parking place (use map to verify)? Y/N
The answer to all of the appropriate questions above must be “Yes.” If the answer to any of the above is “No,” the use of PC is/was not proper. During auditing, the answers must be backed up by the supporting documents (dispatch records, the driver’s assigned/intended route line, the destination of the personal conveyance, maintenance reports, and expense receipts). If the use of PC was not proper, the driver has or will be submitted a false log.
Key to remember: To use personal conveyance, all conditions discussed in the interpretation and the FAQs (and condensed into the list above) must be met.