OSHRC reduces machine guarding violation from willful to serious
In a recent case, the Occupational Safety and Health Review Commission (OSHRC) dropped a company’s willful violation down to a serious violation, reducing the original penalty from $49,000 to $3,500.
Background
In 2012, an operator was injured while operating a lathe. To prevent a reoccurrence, the company reprogrammed its lathes so that the machines stop but do not power off between production cycles, and the operators must manually push a button to initiate the next cycle.
In April 2014, OSHA conducted an inspection of the company's facility in response to an employee complaint, and issued a willful citation alleging a violation of §1910.212 for failing to provide adequate machine guarding.
At issue
OSHA said the violation was willful because the company had a heightened awareness of the cited standard’s requirement to guard against moving parts due to (1) a prior citation and its means of abatement (installing guards); (2) warnings given to operators and posted on the machines; and (3) the 2012 accident involving the lathe operator.
OSHRC, however, ruled it was not willful because the company reasonably believed it had eliminated exposure to moving parts when it reprogrammed the machine. The violation was recharacterized as serious and the original penalty was reduced from $49,000 to $3,500.