Federal judge blocks parts of DEI-related Executive Orders
On February 21 a federal judge in Maryland blocked parts of two Executive Orders (EOs) that limited workplace diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) programs.
The EOs, issued a month prior to the ruling, directed federal agencies to terminate all DEI initiatives and encouraged private companies to do the same.
In the case, National Association of Diversity Officers in Higher Education, et al. v. Donald J. Trump, et al., the judge indicated that the president’s orders likely violated the Constitution; specifically, First Amendment free speech protections as well as Fifth Amendment due process protections because of vague language.
The EOs affected by this ruling are EO 14151, “Ending Radical and Wasteful Government DEI Programs and Preferencing,” and EO 14173, “Ending Illegal Discrimination and Restoring Merit-Based Opportunity.”
Three provisions of the EOs were blocked:
- Termination of Equity-Related Contracts and Grants – A directive for federal agencies to cancel funding for any programs deemed “equity-related.”
- DEI Certification Requirement for Federal Contractors – A rule forcing contractors to certify that they do not operate any DEI programs that violate federal law, with potential penalties under the False Claims Act.
- Enforcement Threat Provision – A directive for the Attorney General to encourage private-sector investigations into “illegal DEI” programs, without defining what those are.
What this ruling means for employers
Employers may interpret this ruling as permission to continue DEI programs without immediate threat of federal enforcement. However, this is a preliminary injunction, and the government is likely to appeal.
Employers should watch for further legal developments, and in the meantime continue to make sure policies and initiatives do not prioritize race or sex over individual merit and aptitude in hiring or other employment actions. Promoting a respectful workplace continues to be a best practice.
Key to remember: A federal judge in Maryland blocked parts of two Executive Orders that limited workplace diversity, equity, and inclusion programs. This is a preliminary injunction, and the government is likely to appeal.