EEOC defines ‘illegal DEI’
Diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) programs have come under scrutiny in several executive orders this year, and on March 19 the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) offered some information on how a DEI program could violate the law.
The EEOC, which enforces the federal workplace anti-discrimination laws, provided information on what constitutes illegal DEI policies and practices. The information also came from the Department of Justice, which shares jurisdiction with the EEOC over employment discrimination for public sector employers.
Executive orders signed in January, including Executive Order (EO) 14173 “Ending Illegal Discrimination and Restoring Merit-Based Opportunity,” have questioned the legality of DEI programs.
The term “DEI” isn’t defined in Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (Title VII), and employers have been waiting for a definition.
Generally, DEI initiatives, policies, programs, or practices can be illegal if they involve taking an employment action motivated — in whole or in part — by an employee’s or applicant’s race, sex, or another protected characteristic. This includes:
- Using quotas or otherwise “balancing” a workforce by race, sex, or other protected traits.
- Employer-sponsored employee activities (such as those that make company time, facilities, or premises available) and other forms of official or unofficial encouragement or participation, such as employee clubs or groups.
- Limiting membership in workplace groups, such as Employee Resource Groups (ERG), Business Resource Groups (BRGs), or other employee affinity groups, to certain protected groups. Such groups should be open to all employees, regardless of characteristics. Employers also should ensure that employees of all backgrounds have equal access to workplace networks.
Employers should offer thoughtful training and mentoring that provides workers of all backgrounds with the opportunity, skill, experience, and information necessary to perform well, and to ascend to upper-level jobs.
Can DEI training be discriminatory?
Harassment is illegal when it is so frequent or severe that a reasonable person would find it to be intimidating, hostile, or abusive. Depending on the facts of the situation, the EEOC notes that an employee may be able to plausibly allege or prove that a diversity or other training relating to DEI created a hostile work environment (which is a form of harassment) by showing that the training was discriminatory in its design or execution. Individuals might be able to prove that diversity or DEI-related training created a hostile work environment by showing that the training was discriminatory in:
- Content,
- Application, or
- Context.
An employee’s opposition to DEI training may be a protected activity if the employee provides a fact-specific basis for the belief that the training violates the law. The EEOC information notes that in cases alleging a hostile work environment, courts have ruled in favor of plaintiffs who present evidence that the training was discriminatory. For example, repeated training that subjects male employees to unwelcome touching to show how that makes female employees feel could create a hostile work environment.
A single training session that merely makes an employee uncomfortable or uneasy would not create a hostile work environment, however.
Most DEI training is designed to help employees understand differences and encourage respect in the workplace and would not cross the line into discrimination when conducted appropriately.
Key to remember: Employers may still have inclusion practices, but they should be open to all employees, regardless of protected characteristics.