Rejection of honest applicant drives trucking company to court
A Pennsylvania-based trucking company assumed they were saving time and money by dismissing a job applicant who was forthcoming about a past criminal record during an interview.
The company had informed the applicant they would run a criminal background check, prompting the applicant to tell them what that report would likely reveal; that 15 years earlier, he had been convicted of armed robbery and served 6 years in prison.
The company immediately rejected him, saying he wouldn’t be hired because of that conviction. Thanks to the wannabe driver’s honesty, they moved on without having to pay for a criminal background check. In the end, however, their decision cost them more time and money than ordering a background check would have.
The courts weigh in
After being dismissed from the hiring process, the applicant sued the trucking company, arguing that the rejection violated Pennsylvania’s Criminal History Record Information Act. The Act is a state law that defines how employers can use a person’s criminal past when making hiring decisions. Under the law, employers must:
- Show that a conviction relates to whether someone can do the job in question, and
- Put it in writing if they turn down an applicant based on criminal history.
A district court threw out the case, saying that the law applies only when employers obtain criminal records from state agencies, not when applicants disclose information themselves.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit disagreed. In reversing the lower court’s decision, the judge explained that the statute focuses on what kind of information an employer receives, not where it comes from. The law protects information that is part of someone's criminal history record, regardless of the source.
The key distinction, the court found, is between the type of information and its origin. When the applicant disclosed his robbery conviction, the company received information that exists in his criminal history record file maintained by state agencies. That triggered the law's protections, even though the company learned about it directly from the applicant rather than through an official background check.
No impact on ‘ban-the-box’ laws
The trucking company argued that interpreting the law this way would make legislation known as “ban-the-box” laws meaningless. Local ban-the-box ordinances prohibit employers from asking about criminal history on job applications. But the court rejected that reasoning. Pennsylvania's law doesn’t stop employers from asking about convictions; it just limits what they can do with the answers. Ban-the-box laws are another layer of protection cities can choose to require.
The company also tried to use an exception in the statute for information from certain public sources like court documents and police blotters. The court wasn’t persuaded by this argument because even if that exception applied to hiring discrimination claims, it doesn’t cover what an applicant voluntarily shares. The law lists specific exempted sources, and by omitting applicant disclosures from that list, the legislature signaled they shouldn’t be exempt.
The decision sent the case back to the lower court, where the company will have to defend its actions. That means the trucking company must show why the applicant’s robbery conviction makes him unsuitable to drive their trucks, and whether the company provided proper written notice when it turned him down.
Employers, especially those in Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Delaware, and the Virgin Islands – the states covered by the Third Circuit – should be aware that this ruling clarifies that criminal history laws apply uniformly. The protections don’t disappear if an applicant chooses to be honest during the hiring process.
Key to remember: A federal circuit court ruled that learning about a criminal conviction from a job applicant triggered the same legal protections as learning about it through an official background check during the hiring process.
























































