Yes, a disability can be temporary
At the end of September, Andrew injured his back at work. Despite the pain, he continued to work but performed light-duty tasks as he underwent chiropractic care. He had bending and lifting restrictions. After 48 days, he was released without restrictions.
While still on light duty, Andrew was asked to perform a task that interfered with a medical appointment and required him to avoid his restrictions. His boss told him they would find someone else for the task, and Andrew continued working.
The next day Andrew’s employer fired him, purportedly because he failed to “follow the day off request process as well as other policies” when he did not allegedly show up for a work assignment the day before.
Employer violated the ADA
Andrew sued, claiming that the employer discriminated against him because of his back injury and failed to accommodate him in violation of the federal Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA).
The employer claimed, in part, that Andrew’s injury wasn’t a disability because it was temporary.
The court disagreed with the employer. It agreed that, at one point, the U.S. Supreme Court had held that an impairment must be “permanent or long term” to qualify as a disability. Congress, however, subsequently rejected the Supreme Court’s permanency standard.
In passing the ADA Amendments Act in 2008, Congress mandated that the “definition of disability…shall be construed in favor of broad coverage of individuals” and “to the maximum extent permitted.”
In response, the EEOC explained that even an impairment that is expected to last less than six months can constitute an actual disability “if it substantially limits the ability of an individual to perform a major life activity as compared to most people in the general population.”
The court in Andrew’s case admitted that all short-term impairments do not necessarily rise to the level of disabilities under the ADA. Employees still must demonstrate that the resulting impairment substantially limits major life activities. Andrew successfully demonstrated this.
Morgan v. Alison Crane & Rigging LLC, Third Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 23-1747, September 4, 2024.
Key to remember: Disabilities can be temporary. Employers should focus less on whether an employee has an actual disability and more on what they can do to help the employee, particularly by providing a reasonable accommodation, even if the employee’s condition and need for accommodation are temporary.