Court: Employers may ask employees about their vaccinations
The federal Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) restricts when employers may ask employees medical questions or require medical exams. During the COVID-19 pandemic, this came to light as employers often wanted to know if their employees were vaccinated to help protect others in the workplace. In the midst of one of the worst influenza (flu) outbreaks this season, employers might wonder about their employees’ current flu vaccination status.
An employer recently learned that they may ask employees about their vaccination status.
The story
In response to the COVID-19 pandemic, an employer implemented a company-wide vaccine mandate. It notified employees that they could seek a religious or medical exemption, but that it would terminate those who didn’t comply.
Jennifer and Katherine, two remote employees, requested religious exemptions.
The employer denied both requests and eventually fired them.
Both employees sued, bringing disability discrimination claims under the ADA. They argued that their employer made:
- Unlawful medical examinations or inquiries, and
- Regarded them as having a disability.
The employees stated that their employer had no valid business reason to inquire into their vaccination status, especially because they were remote employees.
The employees also argued that the employer regarded them as disabled because they were unvaccinated and then fired them for that reason.
The ruling
The ADA defines a disability as a “physical or mental impairment that substantially limits one or more of the individual’s major life activities.” The court said that whether a person is vaccinated or not has no bearing on their ability to engage in major life activities.
The court also said that the employees’ medical exam or inquiry argument was also fatally flawed because an employer’s inquiry into an employee’s vaccination status isn’t disability related.
Finally, a person is “regarded as” having a disability if they’re “subjected to an action prohibited under [the ADA] because of an actual or perceived physical or mental impairment, whether or not the impairment limits or is perceived to limit a major life activity.”
Once again, being unvaccinated isn’t a physical or mental impairment. Being unvaccinated, therefore, doesn’t support a “regarded as” claim.
The court ruled that the employer didn’t violate the ADA when it asked about the employees’ vaccination status or when it fired them for being unvaccinated.
Finn v. Humane Society of the United States, Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 4-1416, November 20, 2025.
Key to remember: According to at least one court, employers don’t violate the ADA if they ask employees about their vaccination status.

























































