NewsIndustry NewsPerformance ManagementPerformance ManagementEmployee RelationsHR GeneralistEmployee RelationsFocus AreaIn-Depth ArticleUSAPerformance AppraisalsEnglishHR ManagementAssociate RelationsHuman Resources
5 tips for new supervisors who fear giving negative feedback
2023-10-16T05:00:00Z
Delivering feedback to employees, especially negative feedback, is challenging even for seasoned managers. Someone new to the role of frontline supervisor, however, is likely to find critiquing the performance of team members especially tough.
Here are five tips to share with new supervisors (or long-time supervisors who are struggling) to help boost their feedback-giving confidence:
- Earn trust first. If a supervisor corrects a team member after weeks or months of not delivering any feedback, it’s likely not going to go well. That’s why new supervisors should not wait to communicate or give feedback until there is something negative to share. Giving negative input without first establishing trust means people will have a harder time accepting that feedback. A new supervisor should try to get to know each team member, including their aspirations and goals. Once it is established that the supervisor supports a team member’s development, it is possible to link feedback to goals. In other words, feedback will then be focused on the future, not the past.
- Don’t delay when negative feedback must be shared. Given how uncomfortable it can be to supply negative feedback to others, a supervisor’s first instinct may be to procrastinate. Supervisors should incorporate regular feedback sessions, like one-on-ones, into the team’s schedule. That way, when there is negative feedback to share, a meeting in which to do so is already on the calendar.
- Decide if (and when) feedback is even worth giving. Sometimes delivering negative feedback at the wrong time can make a bad situation worse. A supervisor should not give negative feedback in such a way as to embarrass an employee in front of others. It is helpful to take time to consider the team’s goals before meeting with the employee in private. Filter out any comments or suggestions that won’t be useful in helping the employee overcome obstacles keeping the team from reaching its goals.
- Don’t just talk. The supervisor shouldn’t be the only one talking during a one-on-one or performance meeting. Healthy two-way dialogue should be part of any such meeting. Listen and respond when necessary.
- Follow up. Feedback is only beneficial if it’s followed up. After a supervisor has a conversation with a direct report it is important to check in and see how they have progressed.
Key to remember: Someone new to the role of frontline supervisor may find critiquing the performance of team members anxiety inducing and could benefit from some these tips.






















































