What might you pay the FMCSA?
A J. J. Keller analysis of enforcement data from 2021-2024 reveals the price you could pay for violations of the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations.
Last year alone, motor carriers and other companies regulated by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) paid nearly $27.3 million in fines, averaging over $7,000 per company. These figures are up slightly from the $26.7 million in fines paid the prior year, at just under $7,000 per settlement.
The following table shows the average fine (civil penalty) that motor carriers paid for the top 15 most cited* violations found during FMCSA investigations and audits over the four-year span from 2021–2024, including the top penalty paid by any company.
*NOTE: The list is based on all cited violations that, individually, resulted in a fine after an audit. Other common violations are not included if they did not result in a monetary penalty.
Violation | Average Settlement | Top Settlement |
---|---|---|
Allowing or requiring someone to drive without a current, valid CDL or permit. (383.37(a)) | $3,531 | $21,600 |
Making or allowing drivers to falsify their logs. (395.8(e)(1)) | $7,092 | $55,080 |
Using a driver before receiving a negative pre-employment drug test result. (382.301(a)) | $5,431 | $15,410 |
Failing to require drivers to prepare logs using appropriate method. (395.8(a)(1)) | $6,204 | $72,900 |
Failing to systematically inspect, repair, and maintain vehicles. (396.3(a)) | $4,603 | $21,550 |
Allowing or requiring unsafe operation of a vehicle. (396.7(a)) | $3,224 | $12,550 |
Failing to implement a random testing program. (382.305) | $6,705 | $18,170 |
Using a driver known to have tested positive for drugs. (382.215) | $7,773 | $18,170 |
Failing to implement any alcohol and/or drug testing program. (382.115(a)) | $5,984 | $15,876 |
Operating a vehicle in violation of a new-entrant out-of-service order. (385.331) | $3,374 | $11,800 |
Failing to maintain initial driving record in driver’s file. (391.51(b)(2)) | $778 | $3,600 |
Failing to keep drivers’ logs or supporting documents for 6 months. (395.8(k)(1)) | $4,839 | $28,800 |
Failing to conduct random drug testing at the applicable annual rate. (382.305(b)(2)) | $7,189 | $42,210 |
Operating a vehicle after the effective date of a new-entrant out-of-service order. (385.325(c)) | $3,333 | $15,410 |
Operating a vehicle after refusing to undergo a new-entrant safety audit. (385.337(b)) | $3,694 | $15,410 |