EEOC focuses on protecting American workers from discrimination
National origin discrimination has been getting more attention in recent months as the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity (EEOC) has focused on protecting American workers.
Two recent EEOC lawsuits involving farm workers resulted in charges of national origin discrimination.
Preferred treatment for foreign workers
In the first case, a Mississippi farming operation began hiring immigrant agricultural workers from a foreign country to supplement its existing workforce which had consisted of farm workers of American national origin.
The EEOC alleged that the farm operation discriminated against American workers by giving foreign workers preferential job assignments which were less strenuous, and came with more work hours, higher pay, and higher bonuses.
Stereotyping Americans?
In the second case, a Wisconsin dairy got in trouble with the EEOC. The dairy promised three Mexican nationals professional and/or management positions when they were hired and gave the same information to the U.S. Embassy for their visa applications.
When the three Mexican nationals arrived on the farm, however, the dairy denied the promised positions and instead gave them laborer positions and assigned them more difficult tasks and shifts. When a Mexican worker complained, a manager at the dairy justified the work assignment with a negative stereotype of American workers, saying “Americans are lazy,” according to the suit.
Even though the Mexican workers were not given the higher positions they were promised, this situation was viewed by the EEOC as discrimination against American workers because the employer was stereotyping Americans as “lazy.”
Title VII violations
Both the Mississippi farming operation and the Wisconsin dairy’s alleged conduct violated Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibits national origin discrimination.
The EEOC recently issued technical assistance on discrimination against American workers, including common business reasons for preferring foreign workers which may result in illegal national origin discrimination, violating Title VII.
The guidance specified that the following considerations don't excuse an employer’s decision to hire foreign workers over American workers:
- Customer or client preference;
- Lower cost of labor (whether due to “under the table” payment, or abuse of certain visa-holder wage requirement rules);
- Beliefs that workers from one or more national origin groups are “more productive” or have a better work ethic than another national origin group.
The guidance also specified that Title VII bars discriminatory job advertisements and that evidence of such ads can include verbiage that the employer prefers or requires applicants from a particular country or with a particular visa status (for example, “H-1B preferred” or “H-1B only”).
Key to remember: The EEOC is cracking down on national origin discrimination against American workers. The agency recently issued guidance on the topic and has pursued lawsuits against two farming operations.















































