Be Part of the Ultimate Safety & Compliance Community
Trending news, knowledge-building content, and more – all personalized to you!
:
|
The Over-the-Road Bus Transportation Accessibility Act of 2007 authorized the FMCSA to deny or revoke the interstate operating authority of OTRB companies found to be willfully violating the ADA regulations. This is the agency’s only ADA enforcement option, and it results in a complete shutdown of the bus company. The FMCSA does not have the authority to assess fines, civil penalties, or any other sanctions for ADA violations. The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ), however, does have the authority to issue civil penalties for ADA violations. Therefore, the FMCSA — as the agency generally in charge of OTRB company oversight — monitors OTRB companies’ ADA compliance and can report violations to the DOJ, which can then issue fines and penalties.
FMCSA does conduct ADA Reviews and there are potential violations OTRB carriers can be cited in an ADA audit checklist. These reviews must be conducted by trained ADA auditors and can be done alone or in conjunction with an FMCSA compliance review. A few key points of what to expect in an ADA review are:
The table below below includes Serious and Minor violations. Serious violations will generally result in enforcement action. Minor violations are not insignificant and can result in enforcement action if done in a willful or repeated manner. Documentation of violations may be used by FMCSA to take an enforcement action and/or used to support subsequent investigations conducted by Department of Justice.
Audit Area | Serious or Minor | Citation | Violation Description | Type of Operator |
---|---|---|---|---|
Equip | Serious | 37.183(a) | Failure to ensure a purchased or term leased new over-the-road bus for fixed route service is readily accessible to and usable by individuals with disabilities, including individuals who use wheelchairs. | Large Fixed Route or Large Mixed Service |
Equip | Serious | 37.183(b) | Failure to ensure a purchased or term leased new over-the-road bus for fixed route service is accessible when equivalent service cannot be provided to individuals with disabilities. | Small Fixed Route |
Service | Serious | 37.183(b)(2) 37.193(a) | Failure to have the ability to provide accessible over-the-road bus service and equivalent service to an individual with a disability. | Small Fixed Route |
Service | Serious | 37.183(b)(2) 37.193(a)(1)(i) | Failure to provide requested accessible over-the-road bus service and equivalent service on a 48-hour advance notice basis to an individual with a disability. | Small Fixed Route |
Service | Serious | 37.183(b)(2) 37.193(a)(1)(ii) | Failure to make a reasonable effort to provide accessible over-the-road bus service and equivalent service to an individual with a disability who did not provide required advance notice. | Small Fixed Route |
Equip | Minor | 37.185(b) | Failure to ensure that 100% of the over-the-road buses in the fleet that are used to provide fixed route service are readily accessible to and usable by individuals with disabilities, including individuals who use wheelchairs. | Large Fixed Route or Large Mixed Service |
Service | Minor | 37.189(b) | Failure to have the ability to provide demand-responsive accessible over-the-road bus service to an individual with a disability. | Demand Responsive |
Service | Minor | 37.189(b) / 37.189(c) | Failure to provide requested accessible over-the-road bus service on a 48-hour advance notice basis to an individual with a disability. | Demand Responsive |
Service | Minor | 37.189(b) / 37.191(b) | Failure to have the ability to provide accessible over-the-road bus service to an individual with a disability. | Small Mixed Service |
Service | Minor | 37.189(d) | Failure to make a reasonable effort to provide requested accessible over-the-road bus service to an individual with a disability who did not provide required advance notice. | Demand Responsive |
Maint | Minor | 37.203(a) | Failure to establish a system of regular and frequent maintenance checks of lifts sufficient to determine if they are operative. | Any Operator |
Maint | Minor | 37.203(b) | Failure to ensure that an over-the-road bus driver reports to his/her employing motor carrier, by the most immediate means available, any failure of a lift to operate in service. | Any Operator |
Maint | Minor | 37.203(c) | Failure to take an over-the-road bus (OTRB) out of service when the lift is discovered to be inoperative before the beginning of the OTRB’s next trip and repair of the lift. | Any Operator |
Trng | Minor | 37.209 | Failure to provide appropriate ADA related training to establish required employee proficiency or to provide refresher training to personnel as needed to maintain proficiency. | Any Operator |
The Over-the-Road Bus Transportation Accessibility Act of 2007 authorized the FMCSA to deny or revoke the interstate operating authority of OTRB companies found to be willfully violating the ADA regulations. This is the agency’s only ADA enforcement option, and it results in a complete shutdown of the bus company. The FMCSA does not have the authority to assess fines, civil penalties, or any other sanctions for ADA violations. The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ), however, does have the authority to issue civil penalties for ADA violations. Therefore, the FMCSA — as the agency generally in charge of OTRB company oversight — monitors OTRB companies’ ADA compliance and can report violations to the DOJ, which can then issue fines and penalties.
FMCSA does conduct ADA Reviews and there are potential violations OTRB carriers can be cited in an ADA audit checklist. These reviews must be conducted by trained ADA auditors and can be done alone or in conjunction with an FMCSA compliance review. A few key points of what to expect in an ADA review are:
The table below below includes Serious and Minor violations. Serious violations will generally result in enforcement action. Minor violations are not insignificant and can result in enforcement action if done in a willful or repeated manner. Documentation of violations may be used by FMCSA to take an enforcement action and/or used to support subsequent investigations conducted by Department of Justice.
Audit Area | Serious or Minor | Citation | Violation Description | Type of Operator |
---|---|---|---|---|
Equip | Serious | 37.183(a) | Failure to ensure a purchased or term leased new over-the-road bus for fixed route service is readily accessible to and usable by individuals with disabilities, including individuals who use wheelchairs. | Large Fixed Route or Large Mixed Service |
Equip | Serious | 37.183(b) | Failure to ensure a purchased or term leased new over-the-road bus for fixed route service is accessible when equivalent service cannot be provided to individuals with disabilities. | Small Fixed Route |
Service | Serious | 37.183(b)(2) 37.193(a) | Failure to have the ability to provide accessible over-the-road bus service and equivalent service to an individual with a disability. | Small Fixed Route |
Service | Serious | 37.183(b)(2) 37.193(a)(1)(i) | Failure to provide requested accessible over-the-road bus service and equivalent service on a 48-hour advance notice basis to an individual with a disability. | Small Fixed Route |
Service | Serious | 37.183(b)(2) 37.193(a)(1)(ii) | Failure to make a reasonable effort to provide accessible over-the-road bus service and equivalent service to an individual with a disability who did not provide required advance notice. | Small Fixed Route |
Equip | Minor | 37.185(b) | Failure to ensure that 100% of the over-the-road buses in the fleet that are used to provide fixed route service are readily accessible to and usable by individuals with disabilities, including individuals who use wheelchairs. | Large Fixed Route or Large Mixed Service |
Service | Minor | 37.189(b) | Failure to have the ability to provide demand-responsive accessible over-the-road bus service to an individual with a disability. | Demand Responsive |
Service | Minor | 37.189(b) / 37.189(c) | Failure to provide requested accessible over-the-road bus service on a 48-hour advance notice basis to an individual with a disability. | Demand Responsive |
Service | Minor | 37.189(b) / 37.191(b) | Failure to have the ability to provide accessible over-the-road bus service to an individual with a disability. | Small Mixed Service |
Service | Minor | 37.189(d) | Failure to make a reasonable effort to provide requested accessible over-the-road bus service to an individual with a disability who did not provide required advance notice. | Demand Responsive |
Maint | Minor | 37.203(a) | Failure to establish a system of regular and frequent maintenance checks of lifts sufficient to determine if they are operative. | Any Operator |
Maint | Minor | 37.203(b) | Failure to ensure that an over-the-road bus driver reports to his/her employing motor carrier, by the most immediate means available, any failure of a lift to operate in service. | Any Operator |
Maint | Minor | 37.203(c) | Failure to take an over-the-road bus (OTRB) out of service when the lift is discovered to be inoperative before the beginning of the OTRB’s next trip and repair of the lift. | Any Operator |
Trng | Minor | 37.209 | Failure to provide appropriate ADA related training to establish required employee proficiency or to provide refresher training to personnel as needed to maintain proficiency. | Any Operator |