Compliance Just Got Easier: Stay ahead of regulatory changes with instant notifications on updates that matter.
['Compensation', 'Wage and Hour']
['Overtime', 'Exemptions from Overtime/Minimum Wage']
05/16/2022
Overtime exemption for commissioned retail employees
NOTE: The following information was adapted from the Wage and Hour Divison's Field Operations Handbook.
Section 7(i) of the FLSA provides an exemption from overtime for any employee of a retail or service establishment "if (1) the regular rate of pay such employee is in excess of one and one-half times the minimum hourly rate applicable to him under section 6 [minimum wage], and (2) more than half his compensation for a representative period (not less than one month) represents commissions on goods or services. In determining the proportion of compensation representing commissions, all earnings resulting from the application of a bona fide commission rate shall be deemed commissions on goods or services without regard to whether the computed commissions exceed the draw or guarantee."
The Wage and Hour Division's position with regard to the this exemption is set forth in 29 CFR 779.410-779.421.
Representative period for new employees
Regulation §779.417(d) indicates that the same representative period may be used for a group of employees where it can be demonstrated that the factors affecting the proportionate relationship between total compensation and compensation representing commissions will be substantially identical for all of the employees in the group.
If a new employee becomes part of a group, all of whom clearly meet the exemption based on the representative period designated for them, the new employee may also be treated as meeting the exemption from the start of his employment if it can reasonably be expected that (considering the experience and other qualifications of the new employee) there will be no significant difference as to the proportionate relationship between the types of compensation in his situation from that prevailing for the other members of the group.
Similarly, if a new employee is hired to fill a specific job previously occupied by an employee for whom substantial information as to compensation is available, and if it can reasonably be expected that the proportionate compensation for the new employee will not be substantially different from that of the previous employee, the period applicable to the .previous employee can be applied to the new employee.
In situations when it cannot reasonably be expected that the proportionate compensation of a new employee will correspond to that shown in the representative period applicable to a group or to the prior occupant of the position (as may happen in the case of a new employee who is inexperienced), the Wage and Hour Division will permit the employer to determine compliance with Section 7(i)(2) on the basis of the new employee's earnings experience (of not less than one month) until the completion of the full representative period applicable to other employees in the department or establishment.
Regular rate determinations
A week-by-week determination of the regular rate is not necessary if the earnings are consistently and obviously higher than required to meet the test. However, situations may be encountered where the test is not clearly met and specific determinations of the regular rate for particular weeks are required. This will present no difficulty in the ordinary case. If the employee is paid commissions under a pay plan involving balancing factors, complex problems as to the regular rate are raised.
For example, a guarantee plan may operate on a formula basis which reflects the cumulative rate of the employee's sales work with the understanding that additional payments will be made when the amount due from commissions over the period exceeds the total compensation previously paid. Or, the guarantee plan may include a provision that if commissions allocatable to a particular workweek fall short of the guarantee the amount of the insufficiency will be carried forward as a "deficit" and deducted from an "overage" in some future workweek. In such cases the Division shall obtain the facts as to the operation of the pay plan and submit the matter through channels for an opinion.
In determining whether or not the employee's regular rate of pay is in excess of 1 and 1/2 times the minimum hourly wage, the employer may divide the employee's total earnings attributed to the pay period by the employee's total hours worked during such pay period. Total earnings include commissions, any part of a draw that exceeds commissions, and supplemental payments, if any, that may have been paid to the employee. Supplemental payments means payments that have been made in order to increase the employee's earnings to an amount in excess of 1 and 1/2 times the minimum hourly wage.
Commissions commuted as a percentage of charges for services
Some retail or service establishments compute an employee's compensation on the basis of percentage of the charge to the customer, such as the charge for labor or the charge for service and parts used in repair. Compensation computed in this manner "represents commissions on goods or services" for purposes of applying Section 7(i). Employees whose compensation (either in whole or in part) is frequently computed in this fashion are barbers, beauty shop operators, household appliance repairmen, and automobile mechanics.
Failure to choose a representative period
Regulations 516.16, 779.415, and 779.417 require the employer to choose a representative period and such period must be designated and substantiated in the employer's records. The absence of such a designation is a violation of the recordkeeping requirements and may be grounds for denying application of the exemption. However, in order to avoid unjustifiably penalizing an employer in the case of a first investigation, retroactive selection of the representative period by the employer shall be allowed if such period meets the requirements of 779.417.
Commissions paid to department or store managers
In some cases, a department manager or store manager is paid a commission on all or some of the sales made by his department or store. For purposes of applying Section 7(i) to such a manager, these payments are considered to represent commissions on goods or services, even though the other employees actually made all or most of the sales. The role, position, and function of the manager greatly contribute to the sales of his store or department.
Service charges may be commissions
A service charge levied on its customers by an establishments e.g., hotel, motel, or restaurant, for services rendered by waiters, waitresses. or other such service employees may qualify as a "commission" pursuant to Section 7(i). This is so because a service charge that is completely or partially paid to such employees is keyed to sales since it bears a direct relationship to the goods and services which the establishment sells, and it is a specific percentage of the bill presented to the customer. Accordingly service employees paid such service charges may qualify for Section 7(i) if the other tests are met.
Tips, however, are not "commissions" for purposes of Section 7(i).
Laundry and similar establishments excluded
Section 7(i) does not apply to any employee of an establishment which derives more than 25 percent of its annual dollar volume from laundering, cleaning, or repairing clothing or fabrics, including rug and carpet cleaning, or other non-retail activities, since such an establishment would not qualify as a retail or service establishment as defined in Section 13(a)(2).
['Compensation', 'Wage and Hour']
['Overtime', 'Exemptions from Overtime/Minimum Wage']
UPGRADE TO CONTINUE READING
J. J. Keller is the trusted source for DOT / Transportation, OSHA / Workplace Safety, Human Resources, Construction Safety and Hazmat / Hazardous Materials regulation compliance products and services. J. J. Keller helps you increase safety awareness, reduce risk, follow best practices, improve safety training, and stay current with changing regulations.
Copyright 2026 J. J. Keller & Associate, Inc. For re-use options please contact copyright@jjkeller.com or call 800-558-5011.
