Compliance Just Got Easier: Stay ahead of regulatory changes with instant notifications on updates that matter.
['Wage and Hour', 'Compensation']
['Exemptions from Overtime/Minimum Wage', 'Non-Exempt employees']
05/16/2022
Grace v. Family Dollar, Fourth Circuit, No. 09-2029, March 22, 2011
Decision: Although she spent up to 99 percent of her time performing non-exempt duties, an employee was still properly classified as exempt.
Irene Grace worked as a store manager for 50 to 65 hours per week. After nearly eight years, she sued for back pay, claiming she was entitled to overtime. The district court granted summary judgment in favor of the employer, and Grace appealed.
To qualify under the Executive exemption, an employee must be paid on a salary basis of at least $455 per week, must direct the work of two or more employees, and must have the authority to make hiring and firing decision, or make recommendations to changes in status. All of these were satisfied. Finally, the primary duty must be "management" which may include hiring and training employees, directing their work, maintaining sales records, disciplining employees, assigning work schedules, and monitoring legal compliance.
Although Grace said that she performed such duties, she argued that management was not her primary duty because she spent up to 99 percent of her time unloading trucks, stocking inventory, running cash registers, or sweeping floors.
The appeals court pointed out that she was relatively free from supervision (her manager only visited her store two or three times per month) and even set her own working hours. Although she spent 99 percent of her time in mundane duties, this didn't mean the store went without management 99 percent of the time. The court concluded that while Grace performed non-exempt tasks, she was concurrently managing the store.
By her own testimony, she was responsible for making sure the store ran successfully at all times. Even while running a cash register, she was watching for theft, evaluating performance, or thinking about merchandise to order. The court concluded that Grace was performing management duties, even while devoting her time to mundane activities.
The Fourth Circuit includes the states of Maryland, North Carolina, South Carolina, Virginia, and West Virginia.
['Wage and Hour', 'Compensation']
['Exemptions from Overtime/Minimum Wage', 'Non-Exempt employees']
UPGRADE TO CONTINUE READING
J. J. Keller is the trusted source for DOT / Transportation, OSHA / Workplace Safety, Human Resources, Construction Safety and Hazmat / Hazardous Materials regulation compliance products and services. J. J. Keller helps you increase safety awareness, reduce risk, follow best practices, improve safety training, and stay current with changing regulations.
Copyright 2026 J. J. Keller & Associate, Inc. For re-use options please contact copyright@jjkeller.com or call 800-558-5011.
